Skip to main content

Follow Us

Social networking will appear here

Support Us

Join or Renew  |   Donate  |   Volunteer    

Contact Us

Email: lwvsouthcentraltx@gmail.com
Phone: 361-772-3228
LWV of South Central Texas
PO Box 78
Hallettsville, TX 77964
Copyright © 2020 • All Rights Reserved • Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Powered by ClubExpress
Empowering Voters. Defending Democracy.
HomeBlogsRead Post

Our League's Monthly Columns

Government Power: Separate & Balanced
Posted By: Rebecca Hegar
Posted On: 2026-11-06T00:00:00Z

“The accumulation of all powers, legislative, executive, and judiciary, in the same hands,

whether of one, a few, or many, and whether hereditary, self-appointed, or elective,

may justly be pronounced the very definition of tyranny”

(Madison, 1788).  


James Madison and others at the 1787 Constitutional Convention were creating an entirely new system of government. European countries were headed by monarchs, although the English Parliament had gained authority over several centuries. The French Declaration of the Rights of Man was not adopted until 1789, and the First Republic was not established until 1792. Besides brewing change in Europe, what the Founders drew from were writings, including More’s Utopia (1516) and Rousseau’s The Social Contract (1762).


The authors of the U.S. Constitution didn’t want a system like England’s where power was highly centralized. Parliament was composed of the House of Commons, elected by male landowners, and the House of Lords, then an exclusively hereditary body. The Prime Minister, chief advisor to the King, was and still is a member of one of those Houses, chosen by the majority party. The House of Lords included those who acted as a Supreme Court, a structure not changed until 2009. Therefore, all political power not retained by the monarch was centered in Parliament. Our Founders devised a different system.


Their solution was three separate branches of the Federal Government: 1) Congress, with a House of Representatives elected by a highly restricted class of voters and a Senate, with equal state representation originally chosen by legislatures; 2) a President, selected by an Electoral College made up of unelected state delegates, and 3) a Supreme Court with judges appointed for life. Every provision of this structure reflected compromises among different priorities and constituencies.

 

It is inherent in the separation of powers that the three branches check and balance each other. Congress may enact Federal laws, but the President can successfully veto legislation lacking the support of a super-majority of two-thirds of Congress. Further, the Supreme Court determines the constitutionality of the laws passed, and over time more than 150 Acts of Congress have been declared unconstitutional. The President appoints a cabinet of advisors and the Federal court judges, but Congress must confirm them and can impeach and remove both appointees and the President. Presidents Andrew Johnson, Bill Clinton, and Donald Trump were impeached in the House but not convicted by the Senate. The President and his executive branch carry out the laws, but Congress is responsible for appropriating the money to do so. The President is the Commander-in-Chief of the military; however, only Congress has the authority to declare war. The system of checks and balances should constrain each branch, as Madison prescribed.


Much political conflict plays out in the separation of powers. We have fought long wars, as in Iraq, without a formal declaration of war, and Congress struggles to exert its authority. The President seeks the confirmation of appointees that require the advice and consent of a sometimes reluctant Congress. Lifetime appointments to the Supreme Court have been contentious for decades, and many will recall passionate Congressional and public debates over confirmation of Judges Clarence Thomas in 1991 and Brett Kavanaugh in 2018.  


The constitutionality of Executive actions is also a continuing source of friction. Although there have been more than 900 lawsuits and appeals filed in response to Federal Executive actions in 2025 and 2026 alone, most recent Executive orders to reach the Supreme Court have been allowed to proceed. Notable exceptions include the Court upholding birthright citizenship, prohibiting the deployment of the National Guard over state objections, and maintaining the state option to allow voting by mail. In addition, Federal District courts have paused numerous deportation orders and visa restrictions on 75 countries. The courts have also overruled some tariffs, the renaming of the Kennedy Center, and have allowed wind energy projects to continue. Madison’s plan requires constant vigilance to keep one Federal branch from assuming too much power.


References:

Hughes, S. (2026). Lawsuits Related to Trump Administration Actions. Retrieved from https://courtwatch.news.

Madison, J. (1788). The Federalist Papers No. 47. Intro 7.2 Separation of Powers under the Constitution. Constitution Annotated. https://constitution.congress.gov.

Table of Laws Held Unconstitutional in Whole or in Part by the Supreme Court (2026). Constitution Annotated. https://constitution.congress.gov.


The League of Women Voters of South Central Texas is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit and tax-exempt organization.
Donations are tax deductible to the extent allowable under the law. Tax identification number: 82-5336795